Is an aluminium or fibreglass fly screen better?

13 May.,2024

 

Comparing Fly Screen Mesh Materials - Which One To Choose?

The fly screen has become a staple of the Australian home. Fly screens allow air circulation in hot weather, while preventing insects and other elements from entering the premises. But what type of flyscreen should your home have? 

View Details

The umbrella term “fly screen” refers to a material designed to cover the opening of your home’s windows and doors. It’s easy to think that all fly screens are similar to each other in terms of construction and materials, but there are actually many different varieties. Each type offers its own unique benefits, so it pays to do some research. 

This article will explain the different types of fly screens available and the advantages and disadvantages of each. 

The 2 main fly screen mesh types for retractable fly screens 

The 3 main fly screen mesh types for retractable fly screens 

There are three main types of fly screen mesh to consider when screening your retractable fly screens; PVC coated fibreglass, polyester, and stainless steel. 

1. PVC Coated Fibre glass

Fibreglass mesh is the most common type of window screen mesh, as it’s affordable, resistant to rust and mildew. It’s made from vinyl-coated fibreglass threads and can be used in a number of different applications as heavy-duty, fine or standard grade. The fine variant is great for coastal area insect infestations, while a heavy-duty variant is preferred for harsher weather and high winds. Do note, however, that fibreglass mesh isn’t recommended for harsh weather conditions.

Polyester

Polyester screen mesh is more durable than fibreglass mesh and therefore it’s an ideal choice for pleated retractable screens. Polyester mesh offers the same level of visibility as fibreglass, however its toughness supports longtime use of moving retractable screen parts. 

Polypropylene Mesh (PP Mesh) 

Polypropylene mesh, more commonly called PP mesh, is a new material that is growing in popularity thanks to its durability and environmentally friendly makeup. PP mesh is more tear-resistant and less prone to sagging than fibreglass and polyester, and it has a high chemical resistance. PP mesh is lightweight, mildew-resistant and offers good outward visibility. Coated PP mesh is also UV-resistant and waterproof. 

The 3 main types of fly screen mesh For Fixed Fly Screens 

There are three main types of fly screen mesh to consider when screening your windows and doors; aluminum, PVC coated fibreglass, and stainless steel. The material you choose will determine how effective your screens are for your needs and how long your screens will last. 

1. Aluminium Mesh

Aluminium fly screens are undoubtedly the top quality material available today for window screens. Their protective finish makes them extremely sturdy and durable, giving them a longer lifespan than fibreglass.

Aluminium screens provide excellent coverage and resistance against abrasions, corrosion, UV rays and rust and are easy to maintain. They are lightweight and can come in a range of colours, textures and patterns. Aluminium mesh is rigid and strong, making it more challenging to install than fibreglass, but it’s less likely to tear. It’s also suitable for bush fire prone areas up to a BAL rating of 29. 

2. Fibreglass Mesh

Fibreglass mesh is the most common type of window screen mesh, as it’s affordable, resistant to rust and mildew, and it comes it different colours. It’s made from vinyl-coated fibreglass threads and can be used in a number of different applications as heavy-duty, fine or standard grade. The fine variant is great for coastal area insect infestations, while a heavy-duty variant is preferred for harsher weather and high winds. Do note, however, that fibreglass mesh isn’t recommended for harsh weather conditions. 

Fibreglass mesh is soft and flexible and easy to install, making it a great choice for DIYers on a budget. It’s tight weave is susceptible to tearing however. 

3. Stainless Steel Mesh

Stainless steel is a material renowned for its durability and while it’s more expensive than aluminium and fibreglass screens, its toughness ensures they stand the test of time. Stainless steel screens can be used for increased security of your home or in areas prone to bushfire for any BAL rating. They can also be a good option if you have pets that may scratch at your screens. 

Comparing the different types at a glance

FiberglassPolyesterPolypropylene Mesh (PP Mesh)Aluminium Stainless steel Best forRetractable and FixedRetractable (Pleated)RetractableFixedFixedCostInexpensiveAffordableExpensiveAffordableExpensiveApplicationSuitable for moderate weather conditions. 
Lightweight and flexible for easy installation. Can be used in DIY screening on a budget. 
Not suitable for bush fire prone areas or security or pet screening.Suitable for moderate to harsh conditions
Professional installation is advised.Suitable for harsh weather conditions, coastal areas, high humidity and bush fire prone areas up to BAL 29.
Professional installation is advised.Suitable for harsh weather conditions, coastal areas, high humidity and bush fire prone areas up to BAL 29.
Sturdy and rigid and therefore requires professional installation. Suitable for harsh weather conditions, security and pet screening, and bush fire prone areas up to BAL 40.
Sturdy and rigid and therefore requires professional installation. Durability Can withstand moderate weather conditions. 
Highly resistant to dents and scratches but can tear easily. 
Dark-coloured fibreglass mesh can fade under UV light exposure. Can withstand moderate weather conditions. 
Toughness supports longtime use of moving retractable screen parts
Ideal in high-traffic areasCan withstand harsh weather conditions Can withstand harsh weather conditions and are corrosion-resistant Can withstand the harshesyt of weather conditions.VentilationSuperior ExcellentSuperiorExcellentExcellent Maintenance Easily cleaned with water and mild soap to remove dirt and debris.Easily cleaned with water and mild soap to remove dirt and debris.Easily cleaned with water and mild soap to remove dirt and debris.Easily cleaned with water and mild soap to remove dirt and debris. May require occasional lubrication of the frames to ensure smooth operation. Easily cleaned with water and mild soap to remove dirt and debris. May require occasional lubrication of the frames to ensure smooth operation. Visibility The fine mesh allows for maximum sunlight and excellent visibility Slightly reduced visibility and sunlight due to a thicker meshThe latest in Japanese nanotechnology for superior visibility and airflow.Slightly reduced visibility and sunlight due to a thicker mesh Slightly reduced visibility and sunlight due to a thicker mesh AestheticsCustomisable Customisable Customisable Customisable Customisable 

Factors to consider when choosing a fly screen material 

Ultimately, the choice between fibreglass, aluminium and stainless steel fly screens depends on your specific needs, environmental conditions, and personal preferences. Consulting with a professional can help you make the best decision for your home.

Do you simply want to keep the bugs out or do you want added security? What’s your spending limit and how many doors and windows are needing screening? How often are you willing to maintain or replace your screens? How important is the look of your screens to the overall style of your home? What weather conditions will your screens be exposed to? These are all questions that need answering before you choose a mesh material. 

From there, you’ll then want to think about factors such as unobtrusiveness. Retractable fly screens can be folded away completely, while fixed screens stay in position. While retractable fly screens might rank higher for unobtrusiveness by nature of their design, fixed screens can also come in unobtrusive colours and frames that blend into your window areas.

On top of this there are pleated fly screens, hinged fly screens and the various colour options, so talk to a fly screen expert about your needs and find the best option to meet those needs. 
Fly screens are a common feature in Australian homes but that doesn’t mean that fly screens are a design decision that should be made easily. Do your research, talk to a trusted fly screen provider, and don’t underestimate the right fly screens’ impact on your home’s aesthetics, form and function.

Aluminium Fly Screen Vs Fiberglass Fly Screen (Difference)

When it comes to keeping our homes safe from unwanted pests while allowing fresh air to flow in, fly screens are a popular choice. They provide an effective barrier against insects like flies, mosquitoes, and other airborne annoyances. However, when selecting a fly screen, it’s important to consider the material it’s made of, as different options offer varying benefits. In this blog post, we will compare two common choices: Aluminium Fly Screen and Fiberglass Fly Screen, to help you make an informed decision for your home.

Post your Requirement

Product to buy:

*

Quantity:

Where do you need these?:

*

Locate

Mobile:

*

Both aluminium and fibreglass make good screening alternatives, but it helps to understand the difference between aluminium and fibreglass fly screens so that you can make the right choice based on the application. Let us take a closer look and effectively conclude the fly screen aluminium vs fibreglass debate.

Enquire Now for Upvc Windows

With competitive price and timely delivery, gaite sincerely hope to be your supplier and partner.

Fiberglass Fly Screen

The gold-standard and arguably the most widely used material for Fly Screens, Fibreglass is made from vinyl-coated fibreglass threads and is a flexible and affordable choice the world over. Available in a wide selection of different applications, Fibreglass screens are slightly opaque but it still offers good visibility from the inside. Moreover, they won’t crease like aluminium screens either. Fibreglass provides up to 75 per cent UV protection as well.

These screens can be acquired in both heavy-duty, fine and standard grades. The fine variant is a perfect fit for areas prone to an insect infestation such as coastal areas. The heavy-duty variant is perfect for places where a stronger screen is required to sustain against strong gushes of the wind and harsh weather. The standard grade is the most commonly used one and also the cheapest option available.

Fiberglass Fly Screen Pros

:

  • Inexpensive.

  • Available in a range of options and colours.

  • Doesn’t dent as it’s more forgiving when bumped.

Suggested: Fiberglass windows Advantages

Fiberglass Fly Screen Cons:

  • Not as Durable and is prone to break and fray easily and hence does not last as long as aluminium.

  • Tends to Fade over time due to long exposure to UV light.

  • Darker than the aluminium mesh thus reducing the amount of light getting into the room\

Suggested: Window Accessories for your Home

Aluminium Fly Screen

Undoubtedly the top quality material available today for window screens, aluminium is available in limited colour choices namely dark grey, black and bright aluminium. Aluminium screening can be used both for window and door applications. Aluminium is also extremely sturdy and durable, owing to a protective finish, and has a very long lifespan while also providing excellent resistance and coverage against all weather conditions. Moreover, they are completely resistant to abrasions, corrosion, UV rays and rust. It’s also incredibly lightweight and with the right maintenance, it can easily serve you for a number of years. Furthermore, aluminium fly screens can be painted on as well and are available in a wide range of textures and patterns.

Aluminium Fly Screen Pros

:

  • Strong, durable and easy to maintain.

  • Aluminium lasts considerably longer.

Aluminium Fly Screen Cons

:

  • Aluminium is easy to crease which is usually permanent in nature.

  • Dents and scratches easily.

  • Expensive as compared to fibreglass.

Difference between Aluminium Fly Screen Vs Fiberglass Fly Screen:

    • Durability

      :

Aluminium fly screens are highly durable and can withstand harsh weather conditions. They are corrosion-resistant, making them ideal for coastal areas or places with high humidity. Aluminium screens are also less likely to tear or break, making them a long-lasting option.

On the other hand, fibreglass fly screens are known for their flexibility and resilience. While they may not be as durable as aluminium screens, they still offer good longevity. Fibreglass screens can withstand moderate weather conditions and are less prone to denting or warping.

    • Visibility

      :

When it comes to visibility, fibreglass screens have a clear advantage. They are made of a fine mesh material that offers excellent visibility and allows maximum sunlight to pass through. If you have a beautiful view or want to maintain the aesthetics of your home, fibreglass screens are a great option.

Aluminium screens, on the other hand, have a thicker mesh pattern due to the nature of the material. While they still provide good visibility, the mesh pattern may be more noticeable, which could slightly obstruct the view.

    • Maintenance

      :

Both aluminium and fibreglass screens are relatively low maintenance. They can be easily cleaned with water and mild soap to remove dirt and debris. However, it’s important to note that aluminium screens may require occasional lubrication of the frames to ensure smooth operation.

    • Installation and Customization

      :

Both types of screens can be easily installed and fit most standard windows and doors. However, aluminium screens are known for their sturdiness and rigidity, which can make installation slightly more challenging than fibreglass screens. Fibreglass screens are more flexible and easier to work with, making them a popular choice for DIY installations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both aluminium fly screens and fibreglass fly screens have their own advantages and considerations. Aluminium screens are highly durable, corrosion-resistant, and suitable for areas with harsh weather conditions. They provide excellent protection and have a longer lifespan. Fibreglass screens, on the other hand, offer good durability, flexibility, and superior visibility. They are more affordable and easier to install, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners and DIY enthusiasts. Ultimately, the choice between aluminium and fibreglass fly screens depends on your specific needs, environmental conditions, and personal preferences. Consulting with a professional can help you make the best decision for your home.

Get fast shipping on the best quality Aluminium sliding window handle on Online Store McCoy Mart

Want more information on aluminium fly screens for windows? Feel free to contact us.